If you or someone you love is facing criminal charges in New York, the court process has a naming convention that confuses almost everyone, a grand jury requirement for all felony prosecutions, and a sentencing structure that draws a sharp line between violent and non-violent felony offenses. I have been through the system myself, and most of the fear comes from not knowing what each step is for. So let me walk you through the New York criminal court process one stage at a time, in plain language. None of this is legal advice, and every case and county is different, so treat it as a map and lean on a lawyer for the turns.
Start with how New York organizes its courts. In New York City, initial appearances and misdemeanor trials are handled in the Criminal Court of the City of New York. Felony trials in New York City are handled in the Supreme Court of the State of New York. This naming is counterintuitive: the Supreme Court is New York's trial court for felonies, not its highest court. The highest court in New York is the Court of Appeals. Outside New York City, initial appearances and misdemeanor matters are handled in local courts such as City Courts and District Courts, and felony trials are held in County Courts. Above all the trial courts sit the Appellate Division, the intermediate appellate court with four regional departments, and above that the Court of Appeals.
Step one: arrest and the initial arraignment
It begins with arrest and booking, where the charges are recorded, fingerprints and a photo are taken, and the jail runs its checks. The People of the State of New York, represented by the district attorney, bring the case. The accused is the defendant, and the defense attorney represents them. In New York City, defendants are usually brought before a judge in Criminal Court within 24 hours of arrest for arraignment. At the arraignment the defendant is formally advised of the charges, bail is determined, and counsel is appointed if the defendant cannot afford one. The defendant receives various notices about the case, including whether the prosecution intends to present the matter to a grand jury. At this initial stage the defendant generally does not enter a plea to a felony charge.
Step two: the preliminary hearing
Under Criminal Procedure Law Article 180, the local court may hold a preliminary hearing in felony cases. The purpose of the preliminary hearing is to determine whether there is probable cause to believe that the defendant committed a felony. The court may hear evidence from the prosecution. The defendant has the right to be present and to be represented by counsel, and may present evidence and testimony. If the court finds the felony charge substantiated, the matter is held over for the action of a grand jury. The court also determines at this stage whether to incarcerate the defendant pending grand jury action or to set bail for release.
If the prosecution presents no evidence that the defendant committed any offense, the court must release the defendant from custody. If the hearing shows the defendant may have committed a lesser offense rather than the felony charged, the court may reduce the charge.
Step three: the grand jury
Before any felony can proceed to trial in New York, the prosecution must obtain a grand jury indictment. The grand jury in New York consists of 16 to 23 citizens. The proceedings are closed and confidential. The defendant has no right to be present, though a defendant who wishes to testify may do so. The grand jury hears evidence from the prosecutor and decides whether there is sufficient evidence to formally charge the defendant. If the grand jury votes a true bill of indictment, the case moves to the superior court for arraignment on the indictment. If the grand jury votes a no bill, the charges are not sustained at that level.
The prosecution has six months from the arraignment to present the case to a grand jury for a felony to proceed. A defendant may also waive the grand jury and agree to be prosecuted instead by a superior court information, which moves the case forward without the full grand jury process.
Step four: arraignment on the indictment
Once an indictment has been filed, the defendant is arraigned in the Supreme Court (in New York City) or the County Court (outside New York City). Criminal Court no longer has jurisdiction once an indictment is filed. At the Supreme Court arraignment, the defendant receives a copy of the indictment and the Voluntary Disclosure Form, which includes information about the circumstances of the case and the arrest. The defendant enters a plea of guilty or not guilty to the indictment. Bail may be reviewed and conditions may be adjusted.
Step five: pretrial, discovery, and motions
After the arraignment on the indictment the case enters the pretrial phase. Both sides exchange evidence through discovery, which in New York now includes significant automatic disclosure of materials under the state's discovery reform law. The defense can file pretrial motions, including motions to suppress evidence obtained through an unlawful search or seizure, and Sandoval motions to limit or exclude reference to prior convictions at trial. A successful suppression motion can fundamentally change the course of a case. Status conferences and motion hearings occur during this phase. Most New York felony cases are resolved through plea agreements rather than trial. Whether to accept a plea is entirely the defendant's decision. A good lawyer lays out the real risks and the real options so the defendant can choose with clear eyes.
Step six: trial
If the case does not resolve, it goes to trial in Supreme Court or County Court. A felony defendant has the right to a jury of twelve. Misdemeanor cases are tried before six jurors or, in some instances, before a judge without a jury. Trial moves through jury selection, then opening statements, the People's case, the defense case, closing arguments, and the verdict. Throughout, the burden stays on the People to prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. The defendant does not have to prove innocence and does not have to testify.
Step seven: sentencing under New York's felony class and sentence type system
If there is a guilty verdict or plea, the case moves to sentencing. New York uses a six-class felony system, divided into Class A-I, A-II, B, C, D, and E. Each class has a range of possible sentences, and whether a felony is classified as a violent felony offense determines whether the sentence is determinate or indeterminate.
Violent felony offenses in Classes B through E carry determinate sentences. A determinate sentence is a fixed term set by the judge. Under the six-sevenths rule, a defendant serving a determinate sentence must serve at least six-sevenths of that term before release. Class A-I felonies include first-degree murder and carry life in prison; mandatory life without parole applies to certain A-I violent felonies. Class A-II felonies include major drug trafficking and carry indeterminate sentences ranging from a minimum of 3 to 8 years up to life.
Non-violent felonies in Classes B through E carry indeterminate sentences. An indeterminate sentence has a minimum and a maximum set by the judge; the parole board has authority to release the defendant at any point after the minimum is served. The gap between minimum and maximum is the window in which the parole board exercises its discretion. Prior convictions as a second felony offender or second violent felony offender can significantly increase both the mandatory minimums and the applicable ranges.
Before sentencing, the court orders a presentence investigation. Victims have the right to submit victim impact statements and to address the court.
Step eight: appeals
A conviction is not always the end of the road. New York's appellate structure runs through the Appellate Division, the intermediate appellate court, and then the Court of Appeals. The Appellate Division has four regional departments: the First Department covers Manhattan and the Bronx, the Second Department covers Brooklyn, Queens, Staten Island, and several downstate counties, the Third Department covers Albany and much of upstate New York, and the Fourth Department covers Rochester and the western part of the state. From the Appellate Division, a party may seek leave to appeal to the Court of Appeals, the highest court in the state. Deadlines run quickly after sentencing, so anyone considering an appeal needs to tell their lawyer right away.
A cursory look at the federal court process in New York
Everything above describes the New York state court system, which handles the overwhelming majority of criminal cases. Some cases, though, are charged as federal crimes and move through an entirely separate system worth understanding in outline.
New York is divided into four federal judicial districts, each with its own courthouses, judges, and United States Attorney's Office. The Southern District of New York, known as the SDNY, covers Manhattan, the Bronx, and surrounding downstate counties. It is one of the most prominent and active federal trial courts in the country. Its courthouses include the Daniel Patrick Moynihan United States Courthouse and the Thurgood Marshall United States Courthouse in Manhattan, and the Charles L. Brieant Jr. Federal Building and Courthouse in White Plains. The Eastern District of New York, known as the EDNY, covers Brooklyn, Queens, Staten Island, Nassau County, and Suffolk County, with courthouses in Brooklyn and Central Islip. The Northern District of New York covers most of upstate New York, with courthouses in Albany, Syracuse, and other locations. The Western District of New York covers the western part of the state, with courthouses in Buffalo and Rochester.
The federal sequence covers the same broad ground you read about above but with its own rules and players. After a federal arrest, the defendant has an initial appearance before a United States magistrate judge, with detention or release decided under the federal Bail Reform Act. Felony charges are brought by indictment from a federal grand jury. The case proceeds through arraignment, discovery and motions, and either a plea or a trial in United States District Court. Federal sentences are calculated under the United States Sentencing Guidelines; sentences are served in federal prison, and there is no parole in the federal system.
If a federal case in New York ends in conviction and is appealed, it does not go to the Appellate Division or the Court of Appeals. It goes to the United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit, based in New York City, which also covers Connecticut and Vermont. From there the only further step is the United States Supreme Court. Because federal practice is its own world, anyone facing a federal charge in New York should make sure their lawyer has real federal court experience.
Where this leaves you
The New York court process is long, and the counterintuitive naming of the courts is the first thing that trips up families. The Supreme Court tries felonies. The Court of Appeals is the top of the state court system. Everything else, the preliminary hearing, the grand jury, the arraignment on indictment, the pretrial phase, the trial, the sentencing, and the appeal, follows from there. Get a lawyer involved as early as you can, keep one page with the charges, the court, the next date, and your attorney's contact information, and stay close to your loved one through it. The system is built to make people feel alone. Knowing the map is how you push back against that.
Discovery Offer - Silos 1-2
Search arrest records and find out where they are
If you're trying to locate someone who was arrested or find out where they are being held, TruthFinder searches arrest records, court records, and custody status across all 50 states.